Sell your home with our tailored solution for you.
Sell with usAs AI makes it easier to edit property images, questions are being raised about where enhancement ends and misrepresentation begins.
New Zealand Sotheby’s International Realty Managing Director Mark Harris spoke to Newsroom about the role AI can play in property marketing, and why buyers should be able to trust what they see. He also shared his view on the wider opportunity for AI to give agents more time to focus on their clients.
The following story was originally published by Newsroom.
A real estate agent who uses artificial intelligence to create property listings says one ad he has “AI-ed to buggery” helps buyers understand the home’s potential.
Independent agent Allan Clark says traditional staging, where a house is cleared out then fitted with rental furniture and art to make it attractive for prospective buyers, affects sellers’ bottom lines. He now offers a “virtual staging package” that spruces up rooms and mocks up potential renovations – with the AI pictures placed on an artist’s easel inside the actual room.
In the AI-heavy marketing Clark has developed for the property he’s selling in Glendene, Waitakere City, pictures of a sparse separate unit at the rear of the property are followed by images showing its potential. These picture the building as a workshop with tools hanging on the walls, as a home brewery with shiny kegs, and as a dwelling surrounded by flower gardens.
Photos of the home’s front exterior are preceded by an AI-generated image of the frontage with the addition of a deck. A Sims-esque man is topping up glasses of wine on an outdoor table, while the woman tends to the barbecue and two children play with a dog on a lush-looking lawn.
Two older adults walk up the drive from the back dwelling, again showing its possible usage as a granny flat. A label at the top of the image says ‘Furniture virtually staged’.
Photo enhancement tools have a long history in the real estate industry and have for years been used to superimpose a sunset, make the sky blue or brighten rooms. In recent years enhancement has in many cases made way for AI-doctoring, prompting greater scrutiny on its use.
Clarks agrees that this labelling alone does not adequately flag the enhancements. “So in the text, it says a bit more about it,” he says. “But that’s actually down to the systems at the moment that need to be upgraded with what we can tag the photos with.”
Clark, who has been in the industry for two decades, says he does the due diligence to ensure the changes mocked up in his AI renders are possible. For example, adding the bifold doors and deck at the front of the Glendene property “is not a hard job to do” and wouldn’t need building consent. The response to his use of AI has been “overwhelmingly positive”, he says.
“It’s about not overselling things that can’t be done, and keeping the potential really accurate … you can’t sell anything to a disappointed buyer.”
“Adding a view that isn’t there, making a room look bigger, removing a permanent feature or showing a renovation that hasn’t happened is something else entirely.”
It is these sometimes fuzzy lines that have critics concerned over ‘housefishing’ – misleading prospective buyers with overly polished or altered visual representations.
Recent analysis by law firm Simpson Grierson warns AI-altered images risk breaching the Fair Trading Act if they create a deceptive overall impression.
Simpson Grierson’s litigation partner James Craig says many people will do their due diligence when house-hunting, but the legal test protects all consumers.
“You have to assume that some people just won’t be onto it, and so you can’t make assumptions as to how people are going to interpret it. Some people buy houses unseen … go straight off the advertisement – for example an overseas buyer.
“If the fine print is sort of hidden down the bottom of the listing, it’s not going to be a defence in this kind of situation. So I would see it as a real consumer issue, and that’s evidenced by the approach in the US and Australia.”
Internationally, guardrails are being bolstered. Since January 1 this year California has required real estate agents to clearly disclose where images used to market properties have been digitally altered, and provide the originals.
New South Wales has passed legislation requiring the disclosure of digitally modified or AI-generated images used in rental advertising. Maximum penalties are $5500 for individuals and $22,000 for organisations.
Craig believes New Zealand’s Fair Trading Act is broad enough to capture this developing trend, noting the Fair Trading Act Amendment Bill making its way through Parliament is going to significantly increase the penalties for a breach, to $1 million for an individual and $5m for a company.
Regulators are taking notice, even if concerns aren’t yet turning into complaints. The Commerce Commission has received 47 complaints relating to the use of AI this year, spokesperson Rebecca McAtamney says, but none of these relate to real estate.
McAtamney stresses that using AI does not transfer responsibility away from businesses, which “should be mindful not to cross the line from being merely persuasive, to misleading and deceptive, and potentially breach the Fair Trading Act”.
Josh Doherty, the Real Estate Authority’s head of licensing, enquiries and complaints, says the body issued guidance to the sector on responsible use of AI in 2024, when its data signalled increasing usage.
“AI or other digital enhancement that seeks to help a buyer visualise a property’s potential (such as how it might look with certain decor, or with blue sky) is likely to raise fewer concerns than digital retouching that seeks to conceal a feature considered undesirable, such as a nearby power pylon,” he says.
“REA is starting to see more enquiries from consumers with concerns about the use of AI in photography. However, it is not currently a significant theme in complaints.”