What Makes a Good Property Appraisal?

It is inarguable that a well-executed property appraisal is vital for establishing an accurate price understanding. However, a property appraisal is more than just a valuation tool; it is a pivotal step that enables a property owner and their real estate agent to engage in meaningful conversations, discuss expectations, and devise a strategic plan for a successful sale.

I encourage sellers to make the most of this phase of the sales process. Take the time to ask your agent and their team insightful questions. Evaluate their expertise, assess their networks, and identify their unique strengths. This approach ensures you partner with an agent who is not only well-qualified but also someone you can easily communicate with and trust.

---

Here are the key points that contribute to a good property appraisal.

1. Know Your Market Statistics

Understanding current market statistics is the foundation of a reliable property appraisal. This includes recent sales data, price trends, and the economic environment. At a minimum, your appraisal should provide information on comparable properties that have recently sold in the area.

However, it is worth noting that the higher the value of a home, the broader that area might be and the further back in time you should look.

Key metrics to consider include:

• Sale Prices and Property Knowledge: Knowing the sale price of similar homes with comparable features, location, views and construction helps establish a baseline for valuation.
• Days on Market: This indicates how quickly homes in the area are selling, which can inform pricing strategies and the demand for similar properties.
• Price per Square Metre: This statistic allows for a more granular comparison between properties, particularly properties in prime locations or the sale of bare land.
• Market Conditions: Understanding whether it is a buyer's or seller's market is important for pricing and choosing the best method of sale.

2. Careful Consideration of the Most Highly Comparable Homes —or Not

New Zealand Sotheby's International Realty are specialists in unique and exceptional properties, which often requires us to look beyond the immediate neighbourhood to find comparable homes. Identifying similar properties is a critical aspect of a property appraisal. It's not just about finding homes that are similar in size and style but also understanding their nuances.

• Location: Proximity to amenities and school zones, privacy, access, aspect, sun and views can significantly affect a home's value.
• Recent Renovations: Homes that have undergone significant renovations will command a higher price, even if they are not directly comparable in age or size. Kitchens, bathrooms and warmth are prime factors.
• Features: Architectural merit and special features, like sculleries, walk-in wardrobes, fitted cabinetry, lighting, pools or high-end appliances, can set a property apart.

3. Consider the Uniqueness of a Premium Home

Premium homes often come with unique attributes that require special consideration during the appraisal process. These may include architectural features, landscape design, and interior finishes. Here are some factors to consider:

• Quality of Construction: High-end materials and craftsmanship can significantly enhance a home's value.
• Landscaping, Outdoor Spaces and Views: Thoughtfully designed outdoor areas can add to the overall appeal and value of a property. A north-facing position for sun and warmth, views and close water views all help command a higher value.
• Smart Home Features: Technological advancements and automation have come a long way recently and are attractive to buyers.

4. Understanding a Vendor's Needs and Current Market Dynamics

A successful appraisal process also requires an understanding of the vendor's specific needs and consideration of the current market dynamics.

Understanding a seller's timeline, financial goals, and personal motivations for selling can inform a more tailored appraisal, process and strategy for sale.

• Timeframe for Selling: A seller needing a quick sale may require a different strategy than one who can afford to wait for the right buyer. At NZSIR, we respect that most of our vendors don't need to sell, we are not a mass market agency where volume drives actions, but with that said, most vendors want to sell in a specific timeframe to move forward with their personal goals.
• Market Trends: Being aware of seasonal trends and economic shifts can help in setting a price and method of sale.

5. Intelligent Conversation and Listening

Effective communication is an essential skill for any appraiser. Engaging in open and sometimes challenging conversations with clients allows agents to address concerns, clarify expectations, and foster trust. Key points to consider include:

• Active Listening: Understanding the vendor's perspective and feedback helps set the foundations for a solid relationship.
• Setting Realistic Expectations: It's crucial to convey the nuances of the market and property value honestly, even if the conversation is difficult. The vendor controls the outcome, they only sell when they decide, but it shouldn't hinder advice and recommendations from the agent.
• Providing Market Insights: Sharing data and insights during discussions helps the vendor understand the rationale behind an appraisal.

A good property appraisal in the mid to high-end market requires a blend of market knowledge, careful consideration of comparable homes, recognition of unique property attributes, and an understanding of the vendor's needs.

It's important to remember that a market appraisal is not just a legal requirement; it is a confidential process that lays the groundwork for a professional relationship, successful negotiations and marketing strategies.

A robust appraisal value is essential, but skill and expertise in navigating the intricacies of the market will ultimately lead to satisfied clients and a successful transaction.